Determinants of Ethics: The Roots of Human Behavior

Determinants of ethics are the factors that influence, shape, and determine whether a human action is judged as morally right or wrong, and what guides an individual's ethical choices. These are broadly categorized into internal (individual) and external (social/systemic) factors.

---

1. Determinants of Ethics: The Roots of Human Behavior

Cue Words	Notes
Definition of Determinants of Ethics	- Factors shaping whether a human action is judged as morally right or wrong, broadly split into internal and external drivers
Internal / Individual Determinants	- Conscience (The Inner Voice): ultimate internal regulator when external laws are silent (Satyendra Dubey & Narendra Kumar IPS) - Personal Values & Upbringing: early childhood moral socialization (Mahatma Gandhi's commitment to Satya and Ahimsa) - Cognitive Moral Development: Kohlberg's stages of moral reasoning evaluating ethical dilemmas
External / Societal Determinants	- Culture & Religion: sacred texts and traditions providing moral vocabulary (Dharma and Karma) - Socialization (Family, Peers, School): primary (family) and secondary (teachers) agents of moral education (APJ Abdul Kalam quote) - Socio-Economic Reality: poverty and resource scarcity shaping moral urgency (survival vs higher principles)
Institutional & Governance Determinants	- Constitutional Morality & Law: statutory frameworks acting as baseline external determinants - Tone at the Top: work culture set by leadership (E. Sreedharan setting punctuality and integrity standards in Delhi Metro) - Institutional Safeguards: independent audits (CAG) and whistleblowing protections
High-Yield Ethics Data & Exemplars	- E. Sreedharan Delhi Metro 'Tone at the Top' exemplar - APJ Abdul Kalam 3 societal members quote (father, mother, teacher) - Gandhi 7 Social Sins (wealth without work, pleasure without conscience, politics without principle)
Mains Keywords & Quotes	**Keywords:** Tone at the Top, Constitutional Morality, Temptation vs Sanction, Primary Socialization **Albert Einstein Quote:** *"Only morality in our actions can give beauty and dignity to life."* **Plato Quote:** *"Good people do not need laws to tell them to act responsibly."*
Conclusion	- Determinants of ethics are the **"Roots of Behavior"** — moving from unconscious conditioning to conscious, value-saturated choices

2. Kohlberg's Stages of Moral Development (Detailed)

Cue Words	Notes
Lawrence Kohlberg's Three Levels, Six Stages	Level 1 — Pre-Conventional (Stage 1: Obedience/punishment avoidance; Stage 2: Self-interest/instrumental exchange). Level 2 — Conventional (Stage 3: Interpersonal conformity/"good boy-girl"; Stage 4: Law-and-order/social order maintenance — where most adults and bureaucratic conduct settles). Level 3 — Post-Conventional (Stage 5: Social contract/legal principles that can be changed via consensus; Stage 6: Universal ethical principles — Gandhi/Martin Luther King Jr. type conscience-driven reasoning that supersedes unjust law). Frequently cited in GS4 answers to explain why some officers merely comply with rules (Stage 4) while others exercise principled disobedience against unjust orders (Stage 6).
Application to Civil Services	The transition from Stage 4 (rule-following) to Stage 5/6 (principled reasoning) is the theoretical basis for why probationary training (LBSNAA foundation course) emphasizes constitutional morality over mechanical compliance — a stage-5/6 officer will refuse an illegal order even if it is procedurally sanctioned by a superior.